Feature / Into chartered territory

26 October 2012

Login to access this content

In recent months the HFMA has been thinking about its strategic direction as we look to step up in the wake of changes to the NHS not only in England but in all parts of the UK.  One discussion has been about the possibility of HFMA applying for a royal charter. 

Over the past few weeks, in the run-up to the October board of trustees meeting, the association consulted members on this issue with the simple question: should the HFMA apply for a royal charter? The consultation yielded some 645 responses with 591 in favour and 54 against (roughly 92% to 8%). This is an overwhelming mandate in favour of the move and one the board could not ignore. So at the recent meeting it was decided to apply for the charter and seek ratification of the new articles of association at the annual general meeting in December.

The HFMA is not only a democratic organisation, but one that looks to take the whole finance community along with us.  Therefore the board has picked over every one of the 91 free text comments submitted alongside responses to the simple survey question. Some of these were critical, many were very supportive. On behalf of the board, we would like to say a big thank you to those of you who took part in the process.

If successful with our application to the Privy Council, the new organisation will be called the Chartered Healthcare Financial Management Association (CHFMA). This name was the overwhelming choice of the board because it keeps our existing name – a name that defines our function and for which there is huge affection – while recognising the status the royal charter would deliver.



Membership structure

The new association would have a similar membership structure as today with a couple of small changes. It would continue to have honorary fellows – past leaders of the organisation and individuals adjudged to have made a sustained and substantial contribution to the association. In addition individual ordinary members who could demonstrate seven years’ HFMA membership and be considered senior individuals within their organisations could also apply for fellowship. 

A specially convened Fellows Committee would operate an open and transparent process overseeing the award of both honorary fellowships and fellowships. It would advise the HFMA board on these matters. Fellows would be able to wear post-nominal initials after their name – probably FCHFM – but this would have to be agreed with the Privy Council.

The other change would be to the ordinary member class. An ordinary member would be either a qualified or non-qualified person who works in the healthcare finance sector whether in the mainstream NHS, a private organisation, social enterprise or even local authority. This includes consultants who can demonstrate they work in the health sector, but who may have a portfolio of work in other places as well.  

Only those who have at least two years’ HFMA membership and who are CCAB (or equivalent) would be able to use the post-nominal letters MCHFM, although again this would need to be approved by the Privy Council. Ordinary membership would apply to those who are actively engaged in healthcare finance and only ordinary members could attend branch meetings and vote.

Further along what we hope will be a successful charter approval process, we will publish an access strategy that will outline measures to help individuals further down the management tree. We will consider whether we could move to monthly subscriptions and improve our benefits package. One change is that from the 1 July 2013 subscription round we would move the abated rate bar to the top of band 6 or equivalent (£34,189). Staff below that level would pay half-rate subscriptions.

There would be two other grades, including an associate grade for individuals such as non-executive directors. This associate class (£65 per year) would effectively be for individuals who want most of the benefits of joining but do not work in healthcare finance (in the widest sense not just NHS). The board would be able to bestow associate membership on individuals at its discretion. The final class is affiliate membership, which would be given to those completing the e-learning based Introductory certificate in healthcare finance.

A number of queries came out of the consultation (see right), but we hope any lingering doubts members have had about the application for a royal charter will be allayed by this article.

The board debated these points long and hard to ensure your interests as members were protected. We hope to see you at the AGM on 7 December, when we will vote on the draft constitution and rules for the new association.  If not, please get your proxy or postal vote to us in good time – the AGM notice is published on 16 November. If you have any further comments to make please do not hesitate to contact us on [email protected] .

Your questions answered

The vast majority of members were in favour of chartered status for the HFMA, with 92% of nearly 650 members who took part backing the move. However, there were a few common comments and questions among those that raised concerns.



Why is healthcare finance a distinct profession?
A small number of contributors felt there was nothing special about healthcare finance – why box ourselves in? The reality is, however, that while finance directors have a very strategic role, our principal expertise and specialism is in healthcare finance. By being a member of (C)HFMA, you are not restricting yourself, you are merely joining the organisation that focuses on your sector’s finances. The HFMA is already a respected body and chartered status will, we believe, enhance that status and raise our profile. If you leave to go into manufacturing you can leave (C)HFMA and rejoin if you return.  Being a member of the healthcare finance professional network will demonstrate your professional commitment while you are working in the sector. By being CHFMA we will continue to be as outward looking and forward facing as today – there is no change suggested there.



Will this move be accompanied by an increase in fees?
We can never rule out fee increases indefinitely.  However the HFMA professional fee is one of the lowest anywhere and we intend to keep it that way. While we continue to harness the support of wide-ranging organisations, we will keep the fee as low as we are able to. No fee increases are planned for the next few years and while the association remains in surplus with a solid asset base, we have no plans to change this policy.



I don’t want to duplicate my CPD.
You don’t have to. Once you are transferred to the new organisation, the HFMA will assume that you are abiding by your professional body’s continuing professional development scheme



Will it be costly for the HFMA?
There are some legal costs involved and there is the cost of the paper the charter is actually written on. However, these are relatively minor issues. And our articles, which are based on text written in the 1960s, have been rewritten as part of this process and are now in a much more modern and readable format. So it has been a fairly useful process whatever the outcome. The ongoing cost is no greater than

at present.



It’s a distraction – the association should have better things to do.
The benefits of chartered status are intangible.  However, by becoming chartered we move from being a charity that works in healthcare CPD to a fully-fledged professional body able to ratify its own qualifications. We hope that this will give us greater recognition and the sort of status you deserve as healthcare finance professionals. We also believe many more colleagues will want that status and recognition and we will be able to attract many more members in future.



It all seems a bit pointless without a qualification.
We have made it abundantly clear to all the accountancy bodies that we are not proposing to launch our own professional qualification.  However, we fully intend to develop qualifications that supplement the professional qualification and help ordinary staff in healthcare finance. This is very much a long-term strategy, but one we hope to develop over the coming years.